Yesterday, I went to New York City with a few friends from Boston to counter-protest International ANSWER’s anti-war/ anti-Bush/ pro-palestine/ anti-Israel/ pro-Mumia/ anti-capitalism/ pro-socialism/ pro-comunism /anti-America/ anti-Republican/ anti-democracy /anti-war on terror protest.
We left Boston around 7:30 a.m. There were four of us driving down, Aaron and Tyler from Pardon My English, FReeper Javene, and myself.
We got to New York around 11:30 a.m. found a place to park and got into the action. We had our signs and flags ready. I had a Bush-Cheney ‘04 rally sign and a self-made sign for the event. Before we even approached the center of activity, we were getting looks by passerby. Several negative, as well as a good number of people supporting the fact we were about to stand up to the commies of International ANSWER. A vet came to us and was grateful that we were there to support the efforts of President Bush – who actually had the guts to do the right thing.
We met up with our Freeper James, in New York and started in. We were immediately subjected to harassment from those people who didn’t like our signs. A few people even went to so far as to physically intimidate us. One person tried to rip off Tyler’s American flag.
So much for freedom of speech and diversity huh?
We knew we were going to be outnumbered. We were not part of any nationally organized effort, so other counter-protesters like us were probably there, but we couldn’t find them. However, the support we got from onlookers throughout the day was especially pleasing. We gave out some Bush-Cheney ‘04 buttons to a bunch of people who told us they were grateful we were there to counter protest the “nuts marching in the rally.”
We were engaged by occasional anti-war protesters. Many of whom told us we didn’t belong there and we should leave. Some looked at our signs and said “Are kidding?”, or “Are you for real? These are people who are so extreme they literally cannot believe that people could possibly think differently than them.
Or in reality – just think.

In the middle of the action

Tyler and I get interviewed by independent media
These people were completely uninterested in debating – they approached us not to have a discussion (which they claimed they were trying to have) but to tell us why they were right, why we were wrong, and they showed no interest in what we had to say and quickly dismissed our facts as propaganda and lies.

John and James

Me, holding my signs
Along the way, we were joined by a few people, one of them was John Brose, who just came back from serving Iraq in February. He had come see what was going on with the rally after hearing about it in the news and spotted us and joined our group.
I talked a lot with John, between arguing with the commies of International ANSWER. He told me about how things were in Iraq (which are not nearly as bad as the media makes it out to be) and that the troops are overwhelmingly pro-Bush and are still dedicated to the mission.
Sometimes John was confronted by the protesters, being criticized for his views. Very often he was told “Why don’t you enlist and go to Iraq?” Of course, he would “Actually, I just got back from Iraq.” After that they would usually shut up and move on. I heard a couple protesters accuse him of lying to them.
None of them thanked him for his service either. How’s that for “supporting the troops?”

John Brose (center) in Iraq
There were lots of different reactions to our presence. Once a person did come up to me said, “Listen, I disagree with what you’re saying, but I have to admit you have guts to come out here.”
People like that I could appreciate. He was someone I could have a discussion with. Unfortunately, he was a rare exception.
The signs hoisted by the ANSWER people were quite telling. From the blunt anti-Bush signs like “Bush Sucks,” “Re-Defeat Bush” or “Impeach Bush” to the anti-war signs “Bush Lies, Who Dies,” “Bring The Troops Home Now” and of course “End the Occupation of Palestine, Afghanistan and Iraq,” we knew we were dealing with dealing with a large groups of extremists. Some of them even told us “You guys better get out – you’re going to get killed!”
So much for being pro-peace and anti-violence right?
We took a time out at Starbucks to get caffeinated and reenergized for the rest of the rally. We shared our individual stories from confrontations, and laughed at the ridiculousness of their arguments. After that short break, we jumped back in, and infiltrated the march – which had already started dying down.

Taking a break, posing for a photo
At one point, a rambunctious anti-war protester was screaming at us, accusing us being stupid and illiterate, and I was even called a “Hitler Youth,” – which was not a nice thing to say to a Jew.
But that’s the mindset of these extremists… If you don’t agree with them, you’re a nazi. If you support President Bush, they call you a neo-con. If you support the war on terror, you are yourself a terrorist.
There was some media interest in us. We were followed by a freelance photographer for a couple hours, and I was asked some questions by a freelance writer from Columbia University and I spoke with someone from Salon.com (though I’m not expecting an objective recount of that encounter – should she use my words.)
After the rally died down, we decided to pack up and get dinner. We treated our new friend John to dinner, as a thank you for serving our country.
After parting with our new friends, those of us who came in from Boston went to pay our respects at Ground Zero.

The cross at Ground Zero
We walked around and grasped the massiveness of the holes where the twin towers once stood. We had parked nearby, and it was eerie to think as we approached that this is where it happened. This is where thousands of people died, where people ran to escape the crashing down of the towers.
And it’s sad so many people have forgotten.
Our humility turned to anger when we began heading back to the car to find that the ANSWER people had assembled a small group of people on the platform of the view area of Ground Zero. The were still going at it, bullhorns out, and screaming out hateful words and obscenities, disgracing the memories of those who died there on September 11, 2001.

ANSWER disagracing the memory of 3000 dead at Ground Zero
As we left, we decided to do our best to disrupt this despicable display; we hoisted out of the car window Tyler’s American flag, and beeped the horn as we drove by them. It may not have stopped them, but we couldn’t have left without doing what we could.
Hours later, I came home and had received an e-mail from John Brose, thanking us for hanging out with him:
Thanks for hanging out during that bullshit protest. Well, I am glad I came across you guys, because seeing all these morons in one place was pissing me off and I think I was ready to jump someone. I just can’t understand their whole thought process. How can you not be willing to support someone who is defending you? I was shocked at how almost all of these people had no agenda whatsoever, or even seemed to know what they were talking about. Most of them were nothing but freaks. And what’s scary is that their votes count just as much as mine.
Scary also is that they think they represent mainstream America.
It was quite a day. So much happened I probably won’t get to share, but Aaron and Tyler have each written about the day at Pardon My English, and you can read their accounts of the protest.
UPDATE: More accounts of anti-protests from IvanLenin, Hootinan, and Anti-com.com,